Meteor noises somehow defy the laws of physics


Bright, flaring meteors are sometimes accompanied by faint noises. What’s strange about these popping, sizzling, rustling, and hissing sounds are that they reportedly occur almost instantly to earthly onlookers.

This makes little sense, as meteors are as far as sixty miles away from viewers on the ground, so any sound they make should take several minutes be heard. What’s going on? Do meteors somehow defy the laws of physics?

Your remember that one?

Researcher Richard Spalding and several of his colleagues at Sandia National Laboratories recently set out to study this strange phenomenon, and in a study just published to the journal Scientific Reports, they announce that the sounds are likely created through light.

Meteor fireballs sometimes pulse with light many times brighter than the full Moon, and these blasts can briefly heat the surfaces of objects many miles away. Such sudden temperature changes can actually create sound.

meteor, meteor sound, meteor noise
Wellington man Jono Matla had no sooner pressed the shutter for the last photo in his six-shot panorama when the meteor burned across the sky.

The researchers suggest that each pulse of light can heat the surfaces of natural dielectric transducers. The surfaces rapidly warm and conduct heat into the nearby air, generating pressure waves. A succession of light-pulse-produced pressure waves can then manifest as sound to a nearby observer.

The “dielectric transducers” the researchers mention are objects that readily absorb light, have low conductivity, and heat up quickly. These include dark paint, leaves, grass, and dark clothing. Sky-watchers in close proximity to such objects are much more likely to “hear” meteors.

meteor, meteor sound, meteor noise
Fireball over Banff National Park, Canada in Dec. 2014 © Brett Abernethy

Another incredible transducer is hair. Previous studies have shown that people with fine and frizzy hair are more likely to hear meteors. This makes intuitive sense, the researchers write.

The explanation Spalding and his colleagues offer is actually tied to a well-known phenomenon known as the photoacoustic effect, a process whereby materials absorb light energy and produce sound waves. Alexander Graham Bell originally noticed the effect in 1880, and used it to invent a device called the photophone, which transmitted speech via light.

meteor, meteor sound, meteor noise
Fireball over the Mojave Desert in California on December 14, 2011 – © Wally Pacholka

Astronomers have previously suggested that some meteors emit very low frequency radio waves, which produce near instantaneous sounds. They dubbed such meteors “electrophonic meteors.” Spalding and his team suggest their explanation is more likely, and indeed, it may be preferable to sky-watchers, as it suggests that anyone can hear a meteor provided it’s bright enough and they situate themselves in a quiet area with photoacoustically-sensitive objects nearby.

meteor, meteor sound, meteor noise
A meteor streaking across the sky in the United States. Image credits NASA / EPA.

Photoacoustic Sounds from Meteors, Spalding, R. et al. Sci. Rep. 7, 41251; doi: 10.1038/srep41251 (2017).

Follow us: Facebook and Twitter

1 Comment

  1. Ive heard a few meteors. First time I was walking home at 2:30am on a lone, dark country road with almost no light. Suddenly my surroundings lit up brightly and I thought a car was coming up behind me. But within that tenth of a second as I though that the light got almost as bright as day. From the time I first saw the light getting brighter to the time it got super bright was probably less than a second in all.
    In that ending part of that second I was meanwhile whipping my head and body in a sharp and fast 180 degree turn to see what was coming at me. And what I saw go across the Oregon sky was a very bright meteor, moving straight across the sky, almost perfectly parallel to the horizon, from south to north. It was bright blue and lasted a few seconds until it exploded into green and continued north.all in all it was about a 4.5 second to 6 second, somewhat slow moving looking to me, meteor or some kind of debris. Before it went out of sight I heard it very audible. the classic shhhhhhhhhhhhhh sound. I never questioned how hearing it was possible as a teenager.I just thought that was normal. But later on I began wondering about that time distance sound thing in physics, but I knew what I heard. now after 35 years I guess we know why.
    happened 2 more times to me in that 35 years span in similar scenarios.

Leave a reply

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.